top of page
Search

Understanding Heat Treating: The Foundation of Steel Performance

From the Bench: A gunsmith's guide to transforming steel through controlled thermal processes

By Hootey Cline, Blue Coat Arms Company


As someone who works with steel daily in the gunsmithing world, I'm constantly amazed by how heat treating can completely transform a piece of metal. While I'm always learning new aspects of this complex science, I want to share what I've discovered about this fundamental process that makes the difference between a functional firearm component and an exceptional one.


What Heat Treating Really Means

When most people hear "heat treating," they think of hardening steel – and they're not wrong. But the term actually encompasses several critical processes that modify steel's properties:

  • Hardening: Increasing strength and wear resistance

  • Tempering: Balancing hardness with toughness

  • Annealing: Softening for work-ability

  • Normalizing: Relieving stress and refining grain structure


At Blue Coat Arms Company, we use these processes daily to restore antique firearms and create custom components that exceed original specifications.


Essential Terms Every Gunsmith Should Know

Critical Temperature

The point where steel becomes non-magnetic – approximately 1475°F (802°C). Carbon steel must reach this temperature before cooling to achieve proper hardening. I use magnets regularly to verify we've reached this crucial threshold.


Quenching

Rapid cooling of heated steel, typically by submerging in water or oil. The cooling rate determines the final properties of the steel.


Carbon Steel vs. Stainless Steel

  • Carbon Steel: Contains 0.4% to 1.2% carbon; readily hardenable

  • Stainless Steel: Minimum 10.5% chromium content; martensitic grades can be hardened


Vapor Jacket

The gas layer that forms around hot steel during quenching, temporarily insulating it from the cooling medium. Understanding this phenomenon is crucial for consistent results.


Quenching Oils

Specially formulated synthetic oils like Park's 50 and AAA quench oil, designed for optimal heat treating performance. These aren't just any oils – their chemical composition is engineered for specific cooling rates.


Liquid Hardening: The Workhorse Method

For most gunsmithing applications, liquid hardening remains the go-to technique. The majority of steels we work with are oil-hardening, though some require water quenching.


Oil vs. Water Quenching

Oil quenching offers several advantages:

  • More controlled cooling rate

  • Reduced risk of cracking or warping

  • Better for complex shapes like firearm components

  • Allows for more consistent results


Water quenching is faster but more violent:

  • Extremely rapid cooling

  • Higher risk of distortion

  • Can cause cracking in complex parts

  • Generally reserved for simple, robust components


The Science Behind Quenching

When you plunge 1500°F steel into a quenching medium, the liquid instantly vaporizes, creating that vapor jacket. The key is understanding how different liquids behave:

  • Thinner liquids (like water) shed their vapor jacket quickly, resulting in faster cooling

  • Thicker liquids (like oil) maintain the vapor jacket longer, providing more controlled cooling


Pro tip: I preheat most quenching oils to specific temperatures because warmer oil actually cools steel faster by reducing vapor jacket formation.


Movement During Quenching

Here's something I've learned through experience: always move the part up and down or back and forth – never side to side. Side-to-side movement can cause warping because:

  • The part doesn't fully harden until it cools below 400°F (204°C)

  • Uneven vapor jacket shedding creates uneven cooling

  • The pressure from moving oil can bend the still-soft steel


The transformation from austenite to martensite (the hardened grain structure) happens during that critical cooling from 1475°F to 900°F in under 2 seconds.


Plate-Quenching: The Stainless Steel Solution

Working with martensitic stainless steels requires a different approach. These air-hardening steels would crack under the shock of liquid quenching.


The Plate-Quenching Process

  1. Precise thermal cycling: Stainless steels require exact temperatures and soak times

  2. Controlled atmosphere: Protection from oxidation using stainless foil packets or argon purging

  3. Aluminum plate sandwich: The heated blade goes between aluminum plates and gets clamped

  4. Compressed air cooling: Often used to accelerate the cooling process


Why Precision Matters

Take AEB-L stainless steel as an example:

  • Heat to 1900°F (1038°C) and hold for 10 minutes

  • Fast ramp to 1975°F (1079°C) for another 10-minute hold

  • Then plate quench


This level of precision is why most stainless steel heat treating requires controlled ovens rather than forge work.


Air-Hardening: Industrial Applications

Air-hardening steels like H-13 and S-7 represent the most controlled end of heat treating. These steels harden simply by cooling in room air or with fan assistance after reaching their critical temperature (around 1800°F for H-13).

While less common in traditional gunsmithing, these steels are increasingly used in modern applications where dimensional stability is crucial.


Modern Equipment and Techniques

Heat-Treating Ovens vs. Forges

Heat-treating ovens offer:

  • Precise temperature control

  • Consistent atmosphere

  • Repeatable results

  • Safety advantages


Forges remain viable for:

  • Traditional techniques

  • Budget-conscious operations

  • Learning fundamental skills

  • Most carbon steel applications


At Blue Coat Arms Company, we use both depending on the specific requirements of each project.


Temperature Control Methods

For precise work, several options exist:

  • Digital PID controllers: Maintain exact temperatures

  • Salt/sand baths: Excellent heat transfer and control

  • Controlled atmosphere furnaces: Prevent oxidation

  • Magnetic testing: Verify critical temperature achievement


Quality Control and Testing

As the sole fabricator at Blue Coat Arms Company, I personally control quality at every step. Any part I'm not satisfied with gets discarded and remade – there's no compromise on heat treating results.


Modern Testing Methods

Recent advances in heat treating verification include:

  • Hardness testing: Rockwell, Vickers, and Brinell scales

  • Micro-structure analysis: Confirming proper grain structure

  • Non-destructive testing: Magnetic particle and ultrasonic methods

  • Performance testing: Real-world function verification


Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

With some experience heat treating firearm components, I've seen these issues come up a few times:


Temperature-Related Errors

  • Overheating: Causes grain growth and brittleness

  • Under heating: Results in incomplete hardening

  • Uneven heating: Creates stress concentrations


Quenching Problems

  • Delayed quenching: Allows unwanted transformations

  • Improper agitation: Causes uneven cooling

  • Wrong quench temperature: Affects cooling rate


Atmosphere Issues

  • De-carburization: Surface carbon loss from oxidation

  • Scaling: Heavy oxidation affecting dimensions

  • Contamination: Foreign materials affecting properties


Heat Treating in Gunsmithing Applications

Restoration Work

When restoring antique firearms, heat treating often involves:

  • Matching original properties: Research historical specifications

  • Selective hardening: Only treating specific areas

  • Stress relief: Removing machining stresses

  • Case hardening: Traditional surface treatments


Custom Fabrication

For custom parts, heat treating considerations include:

  • Application requirements: Matching properties to function

  • Dimensional stability: Minimizing distortion

  • Finish compatibility: Ensuring proper surface preparation

  • Performance optimization: Exceeding original specifications


Safety Considerations

Heat treating involves serious safety hazards:


Personal Protection

  • Eye protection: Safety glasses and face shields

  • Heat-resistant clothing: Proper aprons and gloves

  • Respiratory protection: Ventilation and masks when needed

  • Emergency procedures: Fire suppression and first aid


Equipment Safety

  • Proper ventilation: Removing toxic fumes

  • Fire prevention: Safe handling of flammable quenchants

  • Electrical safety: Proper grounding and connections

  • Equipment maintenance: Regular inspection and calibration


The Learning Never Stops

One thing I've learned in this field is that heat treating is both science and art. While the fundamental principles remain constant, every steel grade, every part geometry, and every application teaches you something new.


The research and development work we do at Blue Coat Arms Company constantly exposes us to new materials and techniques. Being one of the few shops in central Illinois with formal training from Sonoran Desert Institute gives us the theoretical foundation, but practical experience builds the real expertise.


Looking Forward

Heat treating technology continues to evolve:


Emerging Techniques

  • Vacuum heat treating: Eliminates oxidation entirely

  • Induction heating: Precise, localized heating

  • Computer modeling: Predicting distortion and properties

  • Advanced quenchants: Improved cooling characteristics


Quality Improvements

  • Better atmosphere control: More consistent results

  • Improved monitoring: Real-time process feedback

  • Enhanced safety: Reduced operator exposure

  • Automation: Consistent, repeatable processes


Practical Takeaways

Whether you're a fellow gunsmith or someone interested in metalworking:

  1. Understand your materials: Know the steel you're working with

  2. Control your process: Temperature and timing matter

  3. Test your results: Verify properties before trusting critical applications

  4. Prioritize safety: Heat treating can be dangerous

  5. Keep learning: This field constantly evolves


When to Seek Professional Help

Some heat treating applications require professional expertise:

  • Critical safety components: Trigger parts, firing pins

  • Exotic materials: Specialty steels with complex requirements

  • Precision applications: Tight tolerance requirements

  • Large production runs: Consistency across multiple parts


At Blue Coat Arms Company, we're equipped to handle heat treating challenges that exceed typical shop capabilities, from antique restoration requiring period-correct properties to modern custom work demanding superior performance.


Final Thoughts

Heat treating transforms ordinary steel into extraordinary components. While the science can be complex, understanding the fundamentals opens up possibilities for creating truly exceptional firearm components.

Every piece that comes through our shop teaches me something new about this fascinating process. Whether we're restoring a Civil War musket or creating custom parts that exceed modern specifications, heat treating remains the foundation of quality metalwork.


No matter your era, we got your six – and proper heat treating ensures your components will perform when it matters most.

Need heat treating services for your firearm restoration or custom project? Blue Coat Arms Company offers professional heat treating with the precision and expertise

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page